10 Classic Muscle Cars That Deserve a Comeback in 2025

The rumble of a V8 engine. The squeal of tires on hot asphalt. The unmistakable silhouette of raw American power. Few things capture the spirit of automotive freedom like classic muscle cars.

While today’s roads are increasingly filled with practical crossovers and eco-friendly hybrids, there’s still a hunger for the unapologetic attitude that defined the golden era of American performance. Many iconic nameplates have disappeared, leaving gearheads with nothing but fading photographs and YouTube videos of their favorite monsters of metal.

Let’s explore ten legendary muscle cars that desperately need to make a comeback on American roads. These aren’t just cars—they’re cultural touchstones that deserve another chance to burn rubber.

The Ultimate Comeback Countdown

Let’s count down the top ten muscle cars that should make a triumphant return to showroom floors.

These aren’t just any discontinued models—they’re legends that left a vacuum when they disappeared.

#10: Mercury Cougar

10 Classic Muscle Cars That Deserve a Comeback in 2025
Greg Gjerdingen, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Was discontinued in: 2002 (last true muscle version in 1973)

The Mercury brand may be gone, but the Cougar deserves to live on. Initially marketed as a more luxurious Mustang alternative, the Cougar carved out its own identity with distinctive styling and refined performance.

Early models featured the iconic “electric shaver” grille and sequential turn signals that made it instantly recognizable. The Eliminator package turned this sophisticated cat into a serious predator.

The Forgotten Sibling of the Mustang

While it shared platforms with the Mustang, the Cougar always offered something different. More comfort. More luxury. But still plenty of muscle when you wanted it.

A modern Cougar could fill the gap between the Mustang and Lincoln’s luxury offerings. Imagine a grand touring muscle car with distinctive styling and enough power to satisfy even the most demanding enthusiasts.

👇 Share this